August 15th, 2007 | Penlight
If you’re a nurse working in a hospital, chances are you’ve recently attended a customer service workshop. I just went to a program on AIDET as part of nursing orientation. A lot of what was talked about was not new:being respectful and attentive, giving clear and concise explanations and including the patient and family in the decision making process. What did surprise was when the instructor said that customer satisfaction scores are now being tied to federal funding.
That got me thinking. Up to now I’ve only been familiar with the Press Gaineys, a private survey firm. I’m sure your hospital has something similiar. Patients are selected to receive the survey after discharge and they rate the hospital, nurses, doctors and other services. It is hospital driven and customized to the institution. In 2005, however, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services(CMS) came up with a standardized survey to track customer satisfaction, wordily called the Hospital Consumer Assessment of Health Providers and Systems. HCAHPS, or Hospital CAHPS, or the CAHPS hospital survey, is a voluntary survey. However, according to this article from the New York Sun, hospitals that don’t report their results can lose 2% of their inpatient Medicare funding. At this time, hospitals do not have to pay to participate.
CAHPS(with and without the first H) are funded and administered by the U.S. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality(AHRQ). The CAHPS program was started almost a decade ago, so that a standardized system of patient surveys could be put into place to help improve patient centered care. There’s a CAHPS for dental plans and another to assess the health care experiences of Native Americans’ use of tribal clinics, among others. The survey results are part of the public domain and available online.
So why should any of this concern us as nurses? Besides the fact that it’s an hour of my life I’ll never have back again. I’ve heard much grumbling from the trenches about how this is just another ploy by the hospital to make money and make our jobs harder. What matters is delivering top-notch nursing care, not being warm and fuzzy. Nurses are a tough crowd with the best of topics, but try telling them that they’re not being nice enough and you’re liable to have a revolt on your hands.
Patient satisfaction is important(sorry, to me they’re still patients, not customers). My experiences as a transplant coordinator bear this out. As I’m sure you know, asking a family to donate their organs couldn’t happen at a worse time. Who wants to make such an important decision when dealing with the death of a loved one? Unfortunately, time is of the essence and we work in a small window of time to make the request, sometimes only a few hours. Gaining a family’s trust is tantamount. I’m not talking about putting one over on people. I’m saying that within the short time frame allowed, you have to not only help the family come to terms with brain death, you have to give them all the information they need to make an informed choice. This doesn’t just apply to life and death situations. Patient education and planning care are synonymous with nursing. Managed care means that many of our patients are only with us for a few days. In the ER or Same Day Surgery, a few hours. It should come as no surprise to anyone that increasing a patient’s satisfaction, increasing their trust and comfort levels, is going to enhance their learning and increase their desire to participate in the healthcare plan.
Hospitals love to have good survey results. They plaster them in the papers and work them into their advertising. So is all this good PR for the hospital? You bet. Should nurses be valued for their ability to start an IV as well as their winning smile? Absolutely. But the bottom line is that keeping patients happy can also be good for their health.

Having spent much more time as a patient in the past 8 weeks than ever before in my life, I can tell you that from my perspective, how well I got along with the nurse(s) assigned to me at any given time made a significant difference in how I felt about my overall hospital stay. I was extremely lucky in that MOST of the nurses were varying levels of wonderful. (I’m sure it didn’t hurt that, as one of the docs put it, I was “mentating normally, which is unusual around here.”) But there were certainly one or two who really had no business working with people.
It’s not just about technical competence (although I’ve told the stories on my blog about the atrocious IV skills I encountered during 3 of my 3 admissions this summer). True top-notch health care (not just nursing care) includes “being nice.” Whether we want to admit it or not, most patients wouldn’t recognize good technical care if it bit ‘em on the heinie. But they do know when someone is nice to them, and when someone isn’t, and both of those are what’s likely to show up on these surveys.
Requiring nurses to be sensitive to the emotional well-being of the client and the client’s family is equal to the ability to perform technical procedures. I have friends who are nurses and have shared with me that time restrains have prompted the need to forgo pain management while inserting “caths”; removing chest tubes, etc. These procedures can be performed in 5 minutes, however with the use of pain relievers ordered by the doctor the nurse’s time with the client is doubled or tripled. So nurses save time and do not allow for the pain medication to take effect. This time can be spent completing nursing care plans and updating computer charting. Just this week my father in law almost died because a nurse told the family she was afraid to call the doctor because he might get mad. After the family insisted the doctor be notified, emergency surgery was performed. The doctor said my father in law would have died. It is so sad that every family I have spoken with have encountered brisk, curt nurses who appeared to approach the clients as a machines to be fixed. Nurses lacking people skills should be directed to an area of medicine that does not require client contact. We are paying a high price for medical treatment; we must insist upon being recognized as human beings, as someone’s loved one. The climate of the hospital can promote healing or hinder it. Hopefully one day hospitals will employ only those who demonstrate technical skills as well as people skills.
Yes, I have reported nurses who have not treated me or my loved ones. More reports need to be filed in order for nurses to understand the founding nurses intent for the field. Docking pay also helps.
It sounds like the new regulations are addressing this issue. After all, medicines goal is to heal a unique human being. Being warm and fuzzy may play a greater role in the clients road to lifelong health.